Evaluasi model CIPP atas kesesuaian dana BOSP terhadap mutu pendidikan vokasi Sekolah Menengah Kejuruan

Authors

  • Jatu Kaannaha Putri Directorate of Senior High Schools

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.66599/wp.v1i2.42

Abstract

Purpose: Penelitian ini mengevaluasi kesesuaian pemanfaatan dana Bantuan Operasional Satuan Pendidikan (BOSP) terhadap mutu pendidikan vokasi, sekaligus mengurai pengalihan sistematis dana khusus kejuruan untuk menutup biaya operasional umum. Method: Menggunakan studi kasus evaluatif kualitatif berlandaskan model Context, Input, Process, and Product (CIPP), penelitian ini mengkaji enam SMK (satu negeri, lima swasta) di Kota Bekasi dengan 15–20 informan terpilih secara purposive. Data ditriangulasi melalui kuesioner 28 butir, wawancara semi-terstruktur, observasi bengkel praktik, dan audit dokumen anggaran (RKAS, ARKAS, Rapor Pendidikan), lalu dianalisis menggunakan model interaktif Miles, Huberman, dan Saldaña. Findings: Hasil penelitian menunjukkan hanya 22% dana BOSP dialokasikan untuk komponen khas vokasi (12% bahan praktik, 5% uji kompetensi, 3% kemitraan DUDI, 2% pelatihan guru), sedangkan 78% terserap untuk operasional umum. Defisit struktural sebesar Rp346.471 per siswa per tahun (pagu Rp1.300.000 berbanding biaya riil Rp1.646.471) memaksa SMK swasta memangkas pembelajaran praktik. Selain itu, empat dari enam sekolah tidak memanfaatkan Rapor Pendidikan dalam penyusunan RKAS, serta ditemukan kesenjangan tajam antara skor persepsi kepatuhan (>4,0/5,0) dan kepatuhan dokumen aktual (17–23%). Practical & Theoretical implications: Secara teoretis, studi ini menyempurnakan model CIPP melalui konstruk ilusi kepatuhan dan pendesakan fiskal struktural. Secara praktis, pembuat kebijakan perlu menetapkan batas minimal alokasi vokasi sebesar 30%, menyelenggarakan pelatihan literasi data bagi penyusun RKAS, dan mengintegrasikan verifikasi praktik bengkel dalam audit keuangan. Originality/value: Berbeda dari evaluasi fiskal makro konvensional, studi ini membedah ketimpangan tata kelola SMK negeri dan swasta untuk mengungkap bagaimana formula pendanaan per siswa yang kaku mendistorsi pembentukan kompetensi kerja di balik kepatuhan administratif semu.

 

 

Purpose: This study evaluates the alignment between School Operational Assistance (BOSP) fund utilization and vocational education quality improvement, addressing the systemic diversion of earmarked vocational grants toward routine operational overheads. Method: Employing a qualitative evaluative case study grounded in the Context, Input, Process, and Product (CIPP) framework, this research examined six vocational high schools (one public, five private) in Bekasi City, Indonesia, involving 15–20 purposively selected informants. Data were triangulated through a 28-item questionnaire, semi-structured interviews, non-participant workshop observations, and budget audits (RKAS, ARKAS, and Rapor Pendidikan), analyzed via Miles, Huberman, and Saldaña’s interactive model. Findings: Results reveal that only 22% of BOSP funds supported vocational-specific components (12% practice materials, 5% competency certification, 3% industry partnerships, 2% teacher training), whereas 78% funded general operations. A structural deficit of IDR 346,471 per student annually (IDR 1,300,000 grant cap versus IDR 1,646,471 actual cost) compelled private schools to curtail practical training. Furthermore, four of six schools omitted Rapor Pendidikan data from budget planning, and a stark gap emerged between perceived compliance (>4.0/5.0) and actual documentary compliance (17–23%). Practical & Theoretical implications: Theoretically, this study refines the CIPP model by introducing compliance illusion and structural fiscal crowding-out. Practically, policymakers should mandate a ring-fenced 30% minimum vocational allocation floor, deliver data-literacy training for budget teams, and embed substantive workshop verification into financial audits. Originality/value: Unlike conventional macro-fiscal evaluations, this study disaggregates public-private institutional disparities to expose how rigid per-pupil funding formulas distort classroom-level skill formation beneath superficial administrative compliance.

 

References

Al-Khathami, A. D. (2012). Evaluation of Saudi family medicine training program: The application of CIPP evaluation format. Medical Teacher, 34(sup1), S81–S89. Crossref

Alam, S., Matthews, J., Sterling, R., Allouche, E., Selvakumar, A., Condit, W., ... Downey, D. (2018). Evaluation of testing methods for tracking CIPP liners’ life-cycle performance. Cogent Engineering, 5(1). Crossref

Anhari, T., & Said, A. (2026). Enhancing digital transformation capacity of educators to optimize school governance. Hamka Insight, 6(1), 1–20. Crossref

Çolak Çakir, T., & Cansoy, R. (2025). Challenges of being a principal in vocational high schools perceived as “a last chance”: An examination in a centralized education system. Leadership and Policy in Schools, 1–28. Crossref

Dizon, A. G. (2023). Historical development of CIPP as a curriculum evaluation model. History of Education, 52(1), 109–128. Crossref

Fathulloh, M. Z., & Ismara, K. I. (2026). Menjembatani kebijakan dan praktik: Tinjauan sistematis kesenjangan penelitian TVET menuju pembangunan berkelanjutan. Jurnal Vocational Education Policy, 1(1), 112–125. Crossref

Fathulloh, M. Z., & Sutiman. (2026). Kepemimpinan pendidikan vokasi era digital: Systematic review dampak mutu dan kompetensi. Jurnal Vocational Education Policy, 1(1), 98–111. Crossref

Gani, F., & van den Berg, G. (2025). Evaluating an online programme review process in open distance learning: A case study using the CIPP model. Africa Education Review, 21(2), 79–95. Crossref

Gilberg, J. A., & Scholwinski, E. (1983). Improving the utility of school psychological reports through evaluation using Stufflebeam’s CIPP model. School Psychology Review, 12(3), 346–350. Crossref

Hermawan, A. (2026). Memperkuat kepemimpinan pelayan di sekolah vokasi swasta: Pendekatan POP-SDM. Jurnal Vocational Education Policy, 1(1), 76–97. Crossref

Kafi, Z., Motallebzadeh, K., Khodabakhshzadeh, H., & Zeraatpisheh, M. (2019). Developing, glocalizing & validating a quality indices rubric in English language teaching: A case of CIPP model. Cogent Education, 6(1). Crossref

Khurniawan, A. W., Erda, G., Tengku Irfan Wira, B., Tengku, A., Arisman, A., Susilawati, S., & Miftahus, S. (2026). Klasterisasi profil sekolah penerima bantuan revitalisasi SMK 2025 berbasis K-Medoids dan Gower Distance. Jurnal Vocational Education Policy, 1(1), 1–19. Crossref

Li, X., Ni, Q., Zhou, J., Pang, S., Zhu, Y., & Song, W. (2025). Application of multidisciplinary collaborative education in general clinical training based on the CIPP model: A comparative study. Critical Public Health, 35(1). Crossref

Molope, M., & Oduaran, A. (2020). Evaluation of the community development practitioners’ professional development programme: CIPP model application. Development in Practice, 30(2), 194–206. Crossref

Muhtar, Suryanti, & Musahrain, M. (2026). Tahap persiapan pengembangan model pembelajaran berbasis proyek terintegrasi dengan desain Dick Carey. Jurnal Vocational Education Policy, 1(1), 31–50. Crossref

Nasution, K. S., Ismara, K. I., & Pratama, G. N. I. P. (2026). Faktor implementasi dan integrasi augmented reality dalam pembelajaran: Tinjauan sistematis. Jurnal Vocational Education Policy, 1(1), 51–75. Crossref

Özden, C., & Kuybulu, E. (2025). Sustainability of social skills course in special education ecosystem: A comprehensive evaluation with CIPP model. International Journal of Developmental Disabilities, 1–14. Crossref

Park, K. H., & Yu, J. (2023). Labor market performance gaps and the role of secondary vocational education at meister high school in Korea. Cogent Education, 10(1). Crossref

Pratiwi, I., & Iswanto, A. (2026). Navigating support and accountability: Exploring academic supervision and its impact on school teacher performance. Hamka Insight, 6(1), 94–115. Crossref

Prihatiningtias, Y. W., Amirya, M., Putri, I. L. A., Lhutfi, I., & Bin Zakaria, S. B. (2026). Mapping AI literacy among Indonesian junior high school students in a Malaysian Islamic boarding school: An ethical-CIPP evaluation approach. Cogent Education, 13(1). Crossref

Qi, W., & Wu, Y. (2025). Vocational education in service of the construction of the “Belt and Road”: Policy support, development achievements and future outlook. Chinese Education & Society, 58(5–6), 269–285. Crossref

Rocha, A. C., Silva, M., & Duarte, C. (2022). How is sexuality education for adolescents evaluated? A systematic review based on the Context, Input, Process and Product (CIPP) model. Sex Education, 22(2), 198–216. Crossref

Roni, A., Suartini, T., & Suciati. (2026). WebCode apps: Mobile learning peningkat keterampilan pemrograman web statis siswa sekolah menengah kejuruan. Jurnal Vocational Education Policy, 1(1), 20–30. Crossref

Syarif, M. S., & Sanabria, N. S. (2025). Sustainable leadership as a strategic framework for enhancing school resilience and competitive advantage. Hamka Insight, 5(2), 127–146. Crossref

Syarif, M. S., Gantini, S. N., Putra, G. K., & Nkolika, C. J. (2026). Principal instructional leadership as a driver for improving learning quality and outcomes. Hamka Insight, 6(1), 21–42. Crossref

Syarif, M. S., Shoko, S., & Umi, F. (2025). Adaptive leadership in managing organizational change: Implementing Indonesia’s Merdeka Curriculum. Hamka Insight, 5(1), 1–27. Crossref

Tardivo, G., & Fernánde, M. F. (2025). Transforming assessment practice: Evaluating a peer coaching mentoring model in secondary education. Hamka Insight, 5(2), 190–214. Crossref

Weller, J., Fogelgarn, R., & O’Reilly-Briggs, K. (2025). The impact of teacher qualification on vocational schoolteachers’ professional identity. Educational Research, 67(4), 504–524. Crossref

Yoana, Auwalin, I., & Rumayya. (2024). The role of vocational education on unemployment in Indonesia. Cogent Education, 11(1). Crossref

Downloads

Published

2026-11-15

How to Cite

Putri, J. K. (2026). Evaluasi model CIPP atas kesesuaian dana BOSP terhadap mutu pendidikan vokasi Sekolah Menengah Kejuruan . JURNAL VOCATIONAL EDUCATION POLICY, 1(2), 292–314. https://doi.org/10.66599/wp.v1i2.42

Issue

Section

Articles